Skip to main content
    Goodbye New York Sour by Proad. Atmospheric mood
    Home/Proad/Goodbye New York Sour
    Goodbye New York Sour by Proad
    Proad

    Goodbye New York Sour

    The drink you didn't order, already poured.

    4-6 hoursModerate4.02023

    As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links to eBay and other retailers can earn us a commission too, at no extra cost to you.

    What does Goodbye New York Sour smell like?

    Goodbye New York Sour by Proad is a fragrance that opens with Red Wine, Coriander, and Davana, transitions into a heart of Geranium, Tuberose, and Cashmeran, and settles into a base of Tobacco, Cedar, and Amber. Expect 4-6 hours longevity and moderate sillage. Best suited for spring and fall. Rated 3.5/5, divisive by the community, 3 votes.

    Updated

    Main accords

    woody
    wine
    earthy
    tobacco
    soft spicy
    moodysophisticatedwarmintoxicatingmysterious
    If this were a songQué Sera Sera · Pink Martini

    The Verdict

    What the community says.

    When to Wear6 votes
    Occasions4 votes
    Pros
    • Wine opening actually smells like wine
    • Cologne that earns a second compliment
    • Tobacco drydown worth the wait
    • Reads warm without going gourmand
    • Lasts through a long evening out
    Cons
    • Opens almost too boozy for daytime
    • Cashmeran can read synthetic to some noses
    • Floral heart divides opinions
    • Can feel disjointed in the transition
    • Needs warm weather to fully bloom

    The Story

    Why it exists.

    Is it for you?

    Made for

    The Enigma

    Goodbye New York Sour speaks to a specific kind of person.

    Is it your signature?

    Create a free account to build your scent profile and discover how Goodbye New York Sour fits your taste.

    Further Discovery

    You might also like.

    Side by side

    How it compares

    —ConcentrationEau de Parfum
    Red Wine, Coriander, DavanaTop NotesYuzu, Eucalyptus, Mint
    4-6 hoursLongevity2-4 hours
    ModerateSillageStrong
    FallBest SeasonFall
    4/5Rating4.67/5
    Full comparison
    Goodbye New York SourProad
    —Concentration—
    Red Wine, Coriander, DavanaTop NotesBergamot, Grapefruit, Orange Blossom
    4-6 hoursLongevity2-4 hours
    ModerateSillageStrong
    FallBest SeasonFall
    4/5Rating4.33/5
    Full comparison
    How Goodbye New York Sour compares to similar fragrances
    This fragranceGoodbye New York SourProadBlue Whisky on the rock, in an old-fashioned glassProadFull comparisonThe Taste Of Champagne On Her LipProadFull comparison
    Concentration—Eau de Parfum—
    Top NotesRed Wine, Coriander, DavanaYuzu, Eucalyptus, MintBergamot, Grapefruit, Orange Blossom
    Longevity4-6 hours2-4 hours2-4 hours
    SillageModerateStrongStrong
    Best SeasonFallFallFall
    Rating4/54.67/54.33/5

    Similar character

    This perfume reminds of

    Community taste

    People who like this also like

    Reviews

    What others think.

    The red wine and tobacco combo either pulls you in or feels like a bar gimmick, and that split says everything. Which side did you land on?

    Good to know

    About Goodbye New York Sour.

    Community recordMaintained by the Silloria research deskSpotted an error? Suggest an edit