Skip to main content
    Old Faithful Fragrance Tonic by Caswell Massey. Atmospheric mood
    Home/Caswell Massey/Old Faithful Fragrance Tonic
    Old Faithful Fragrance Tonic by Caswell Massey
    Caswell Massey

    Old Faithful Fragrance Tonic

    Steam, sage, and the moss that never dries.

    4-6 hoursModerate4.72019

    As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links to eBay and other retailers can earn us a commission too, at no extra cost to you.

    What does Old Faithful Fragrance Tonic smell like?

    Old Faithful Fragrance Tonic by Caswell Massey is an eau de cologne fragrance that opens with Sage, transitions into a heart of Lupin and Larkspur, and settles into a base of Birch, Pine Smoke, and Tree Moss. Expect 4-6 hours longevity and moderate sillage. Best suited for fall. Rated 3.5/5, loved by the community, 3 votes.

    Updated

    Main accords

    woody
    aromatic
    floral
    leather
    smoky
    groundedcontemplativeearthytimelessrefined
    If this were a songFrom the Morning · Nick Drake

    Top Notes

    Heart Notes

    The Verdict

    What the community says.

    When to Wear6 votes
    Occasions4 votes
    Pros
    • Outlasts a full workday on most skin types
    • Sage and pine smoke pairing is genuinely unusual
    • Birch wintergreen keeps the smoke interesting
    • Exceptional sillage for the first two hours
    • The mineral-ozonic opening sets it apart
    • Mossy drydown is intimate and long-lasting
    • Wears closer as it evolves, never overwhelming
    • Few fragrances smell anything like this
    Cons
    • Smoke leans wild, not cozy, polarizing
    • Sage opens medicinal for some noses
    • Sillage too strong for those who prefer intimacy
    • Floral heart doesn't project on all skin types
    • Thermal-mineral character not for daily wear
    • Summer heat amplifies smoke uncomfortably
    • Lupin and larkspur readings vary wildly by skin
    • Hard to find now, discontinued Yellowstone line

    The Story

    Why it exists.

    Is it for you?

    Made for

    The Old Soul

    Old Faithful Fragrance Tonic speaks to a specific kind of person.

    Is it your signature?

    Create a free account to build your scent profile and discover how Old Faithful Fragrance Tonic fits your taste.

    Further Discovery

    You might also like.

    Side by side

    How it compares

    Old Faithful Fragrance TonicCaswell Massey
    Sage’s RoseTSU LANGE YOR
    Eau de CologneConcentration—
    SageTop NotesMyrrh, Labdanum, Sugar
    4-6 hoursLongevity6-10 hours
    ModerateSillageStrong
    FallBest SeasonFall
    4.67/5Rating4.75/5
    Old Faithful Fragrance TonicCaswell Massey
    Santal 33Le Labo
    Eau de CologneConcentrationEau de Parfum
    SageTop Notes—
    4-6 hoursLongevity6-10 hours
    ModerateSillageModerate
    FallBest SeasonFall
    4.67/5Rating3.76/5
    Full comparison
    How Old Faithful Fragrance Tonic compares to similar fragrances
    This fragranceOld Faithful Fragrance TonicCaswell MasseySage’s RoseTSU LANGE YORSantal 33Le LaboFull comparison
    ConcentrationEau de Cologne—Eau de Parfum
    Top NotesSageMyrrh, Labdanum, Sugar—
    Longevity4-6 hours6-10 hours6-10 hours
    SillageModerateStrongModerate
    Best SeasonFallFallFall
    Rating4.67/54.75/53.76/5

    Similar character

    This perfume reminds of

    58% matchSantal 33 by Le Labo
    Le Labo
    Santal 33
    3.8
    Compare prices
    58% matchFahrenheit by Dior
    Dior
    Fahrenheit
    4.0
    Compare prices
    55% matchHero by Burberry
    Burberry
    Hero
    3.5
    Compare prices
    55% matchTobacco Vanille by Tom Ford
    Tom Ford
    Tobacco Vanille
    4.2
    Compare prices
    55% matchEncre Noire by Lalique
    Lalique
    Encre Noire
    3.4
    Compare prices
    Coming soonSage's Rose by Tsu Lange Yor
    Tsu Lange Yor
    Sage's Rose
    4.8
    Coming soon
    Coming soonLike The Very Gods by Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab
    Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab
    Like The Very Gods
    Coming soon
    Coming soonSantal Duo by Le Labo
    Le Labo
    Santal Duo
    Coming soon

    Community taste

    People who like this also like

    Curated Guides

    Explore Old Faithful Fragrance Tonic in our guides

    Reviews

    What others think.

    Sage and pine smoke, does this herbaceous and smoky pairing hook you immediately, or leave you completely cold when you first spray it?

    Good to know

    About Old Faithful Fragrance Tonic.

    Community recordMaintained by the Silloria research deskSpotted an error? Suggest an edit