Do Black Phantom and Smoky Graze smell similar?

Black Phantom and Smoky Graze rate a very similar 79% match on our similarity model. They share 6 notes including Bulgarian Rose, Coffee, Honey and Vanilla. Both lean sweet, warm spicy and coffee.

Which lasts longer, Black Phantom or Smoky Graze?

Black Phantom lasts longer. Community votes put Black Phantom at 6-10 hours, versus 4-6 hours for Smoky Graze. Longevity shifts with skin type, weather, and how much you apply.

When should you wear Black Phantom vs Smoky Graze?

Black Phantom peaks in winter, while Smoky Graze is voted best for fall. Both still work year-round; the season vote just reflects where each shines most.

Which is better rated, Black Phantom or Smoky Graze?

Smoky Graze scores higher with the community at 3.5/5, versus 3/5 for Black Phantom. A rating measures overall approval, not which suits you — sample both if you can.

Side by side

Black Phantom vs. Smoky Graze

Q: Is Black Phantom better than Smoky Graze?

Neither is universally better — it depends on what you want. Smoky Graze rates higher with the community, while Black Phantom wears longer on skin. Weigh the shared notes, performance, and community votes above to decide which fits you.

Black Phantom

By Kilian

Eau de Parfum2012

79^%

Very similar

Smoky Graze

Toouch

2025

New comparison

Is Black Phantom better than Smoky Graze?

Black Phantom lasts twice as long, anchoring its coffee-rum warmth with Bulgarian rose and sandalwood for a structured sweetness that doesn't quit. Smoky Graze throws harder from the first spray, its suede-cocoa-amber core projecting bold and wide even if the wear time tapers. For sheer longevity and complexity, Black Phantom takes it. For initial impact and a higher rating, Smoky Graze answers.

Pick Black Phantom

Pick Black Phantom if you want a 6-10 hour coffee-rum signature with Bulgarian rose and sandalwood that stays the course without needing reapplication.

Pick Smoky Graze

Pick Smoky Graze if you want maximum projection and a suede-cocoa-amber trail that announces you the moment you walk into a room, rated slightly higher at 3.5 stars.

Why this score

Performance proximity

Accord profile overlap

Mood overlap

Bulgarian RoseCoffeeHoneyVanillaAlmondCinnamon

sweetwarm spicycoffeevanillapowdery

This match is a verified relationship from our fragrance graph. The score weighs each fragrance's notes, accords, mood, occasion, weather fit, gender, and performance — the same scale as the badges on every “reminds of” rail.

The essentials

What's different between Black Phantom and Smoky Graze?

Key facts: Black Phantom vs. Smoky Graze
	Black Phantom	Smoky Graze
Concentration	Eau de Parfum	—
Launched	2012	2025
Gender	Unisex	Unisex
Perfumer	Calice Becker	Truong Chieu Sy
Best season	Winter	Fall

Scent DNA

How do Black Phantom and Smoky Graze smell?

Black Phantom

Sweet

Warm Spicy

Coffee

Rum

Chocolate

Caramel

Woody

Warm Spice

Smoky Graze

Coffee

Warm Spicy

Sweet

Rose

Cacao

Amber

Vanilla

Honey

Shared between both fragrances

The pyramid

What notes do Black Phantom and Smoky Graze share?

Top

PeachRumAppleCaramelDark ChocolatePlumCinnamon

CoffeeCinnamon

Heart

Bulgarian RoseCoffeeAlmondJasmineHeliotropeBourbon Geranium

RoseCocoaHoneyAlmond

Base

SandalwoodHoneyVanillaMyrrhTonka BeanVetiverSugar Cane

SuedeVanillaAmberPraline

Notes both fragrances share

Shared note families

Gourmandy Notes

CoffeeRumHoneyAlmondCaramelDark ChocolateSugar Cane

CoffeeCocoaHoneyPralineAlmond

Floral Notes

Bulgarian RoseJasmineHeliotropeBourbon Geranium

Rose

Oriental Notes

VanillaMyrrhTonka Bean

Vanilla

Spicy Notes

Cinnamon

Where they fit

When and where do Black Phantom and Smoky Graze work?

Spring

Fall

Winter

Community taste

Which performs better, Black Phantom or Smoky Graze?

Community verdict: Black Phantom vs. Smoky Graze
	Black Phantom	Smoky Graze
Score	3/5	3.5/5
Longevity	6-10 hours	4-6 hours
Sillage	moderate	strong

No varnish

What do reviewers say about Black Phantom and Smoky Graze?

Straight up, Black Phantom smells like you bathed in a chocolate shop's rum cellar. Not for the timid, this one commands attention. If edible fragrances are your jam, you'll find plenty to love here.Black Phantom

Smoky Graze threads rose and cocoa through the coffee bean, creating something more nuanced than the typical heavy or bitter coffee fragrance. This approach makes it wearable for people who'd.Smoky Graze

The hunt