Skip to main content
    Silloria
    BrandsNotesPerfumers
    Log inSign up

    Side by side

    Enchanting vs. 5th Avenue Only NYC

    Very similar
    New comparison

    Enchanting wears longer on skin.

    The essentials

    At a glance

    Key facts: Enchanting vs. 5th Avenue Only NYC
    Enchanting5th Avenue Only NYC
    ConcentrationEau de ParfumEau de Parfum
    Launched20062015
    GenderFemaleFemale
    PerfumerJames KrivdaAnn Gottlieb
    Best seasonWinterSpring

    Scent DNA

    Main accords

    Enchanting

    Floral
    Fruity
    Sweet
    Lactonic
    Woody
    White Floral
    Amber
    Powdery

    5th Avenue Only NYC

    Floral
    Citrus
    Fruity
    Powdery
    Sweet
    Honey
    Yellow Floral
    Woody

    Shared between both fragrances

    The pyramid

    Notes, side by side

    Top
    OsmanthusRed Berries
    Mandarin OrangeBergamotBlackcurrant
    Heart
    GardeniaDiamond OrchidFreesia
    HoneyMimosaPlumPeonyMagnolia
    Base
    SandalwoodTonka BeanAmber
    Orris RootSandalwoodWhite Amber

    Notes both fragrances share

    Community taste

    The community verdict

    Community verdict: Enchanting vs. 5th Avenue Only NYC
    Enchanting5th Avenue Only NYC
    Score3.5/53.5/5
    Longevity6-10 hours4-6 hours
    Sillagemoderatemoderate

    No varnish

    Real talk

    The berries fade fast, within 20 minutes, the gardenia is in charge. Some say that makes it simple. Others say that's exactly the point: one idea, executed well, no distractions.Enchanting
    Most flankers water down what made the original worth loving. This one doesn't. The honey-peony heart gives it a richness the original Fifth Avenue never had.5th Avenue Only NYC