Skip to main content
    HousesNotesPerfumers

    Side by side

    Tobacco + Musk vs. Xtra Milk

    Clearly related
    New comparison

    Xtra Milk rates higher with the community.

    The essentials

    At a glance

    Key facts: Tobacco + Musk vs. Xtra Milk
    Tobacco + MuskXtra Milk
    ConcentrationEau de ParfumEau de Parfum
    Launched20182022
    GenderUnisexUnisex
    PerfumerSteve Soderholm—
    Best seasonFallFall

    Scent DNA

    Main accords

    Tobacco + Musk

    Warm Spicy
    Tobacco
    Woody
    Soft Spicy
    Amber
    Anis
    Powdery
    Aromatic

    Xtra Milk

    Musky
    Powdery
    Amber
    Animalic
    Citrus

    Shared between both fragrances

    The pyramid

    Notes, side by side

    Top
    CardamomStar AniseWhite Pepper
    Bergamot
    Heart
    TeakwoodSandalwoodBlue Musk
    White Musk
    Base
    ClovePipe tobaccoAmber
    Amber

    Notes both fragrances share

    Community taste

    The community verdict

    Community verdict: Tobacco + Musk vs. Xtra Milk
    Tobacco + MuskXtra Milk
    Score3.5/54/5
    Longevity4-6 hours4-6 hours
    Sillagemoderatemoderate

    No varnish

    Real talk

    Most tobacco fragrances want to be heard. This one leans in instead. Blue musk keeps the drydown intimate, a slow exhale rather than a statement. If you want to fill a room, look elsewhere.Tobacco + Musk
    This is a skin scent. Not a room filler. The bergamot opens crisp and clean, but within minutes the white musk takes over and turns this into something intimate, personal, close.Xtra Milk