Id
Mendittorosa2012
Side by side
Id vs. Black Afgano
Is Id better than Black Afgano?
Black Afgano wears longer on skin.
Why this score
Performance proximity
Accord profile overlap
Gender alignment
CinnamonAmbroxanVioletWhite Musk
warm spicywoodyoudamber
This match is a verified relationship from our fragrance graph. The score weighs each fragrance's notes, accords, mood, occasion, weather fit, gender, and performance — the same scale as the badges on every “reminds of” rail.
The essentials
What's different between Id and Black Afgano?
| Id | Black Afgano | |
|---|---|---|
| Concentration | — | Extrait |
| Launched | 2012 | 2009 |
| Gender | Unisex | Unisex |
| Perfumer | Amelie Bourgeois | Alessandro Gualtieri |
| Best season | Fall | Winter |
Scent DNA
How do Id and Black Afgano smell?
Id
Warm Spicy
Fresh Spicy
Cinnamon
Woody
Powdery
Iris
Leather
Oud
Black Afgano
Amber
Smoky
Woody
Cannabis
Oud
Balsamic
Green
Tobacco
Shared between both fragrances
The pyramid
What notes do Id and Black Afgano share?
Top
Ravansara
Hempgreen notesdavanasaffronthyme
Heart
JasmineCloveNutmegIrisViolet
woodsy notestobaccocoffeecinnamonvioletraspberry
Base
LabdanumBirchCinnamonSiam BenzoinAmbroxanWhite MuskPatchouli LeafOud
agarwood (oud)incenseamberanimal notesguaiac woodmusktonka beancedargurjan balsamambroxanvanilla
Notes both fragrances share
Shared note families
Woody Notes
BirchPatchouli LeafOud
agarwood (oud)woodsy notesguaiac woodcedar
Spicy Notes
CloveNutmegCinnamon
saffroncinnamon
Floral Notes
JasmineIrisViolet
violet
Herbaceous Notes
Ravansara
davanathyme
Fragrance Ingredients
Ambroxan
ambroxan
Musk
White Musk
musk
Where they fit
When and where do Id and Black Afgano work?
Spring
Summer
Fall
Winter
Community taste
Which performs better, Id or Black Afgano?
| Id | Black Afgano | |
|---|---|---|
| Score | 4/5 | 4/5 |
| Longevity | 6-10 hours | 10+ hours |
| Sillage | moderate | strong |
No varnish
What do reviewers say about Id and Black Afgano?
The powdery iris is the divide. Some find it the most beautiful part of Id, others wonder where the promised volcano went. But that's the tension worth wearing.Id
This is not a polite fragrance. Black Afgano opens harsh, almost aggressive with its hemp and green notes, then slowly reveals its smoky tobacco and coffee heart.Black Afgano
Keep comparing
More comparisons to explore
Good to know