Skip to main content
    HousesNotesPerfumers

    Side by side

    With Love vs. Magic Mango

    With Love by Hilary Duff bottle

    With Love

    Hilary Duff
    Eau de Toilette2006
    Clearly related
    New comparison

    Two distinct takes on a related mood. The side by side below shows where they overlap and where they part ways.

    The essentials

    At a glance

    Key facts: With Love vs. Magic Mango
    With LoveMagic Mango
    ConcentrationEau de ToiletteEau de Parfum
    Launched20062025
    GenderFemaleUnisex
    PerfumerRodrigo Flores-Roux, Stephen Nilsen—
    Best seasonWinter—

    Scent DNA

    Main accords

    With Love

    Woody
    Amber
    Warm Spicy
    Musky
    Powdery
    Animalic

    Magic Mango

    Woody
    Tropical
    Warm Spicy
    Fruity
    Sweet
    Earthy
    Leathery

    Shared between both fragrances

    The pyramid

    Notes, side by side

    Top
    Spicy Notes
    Mango
    Heart
    Cocobolo WoodMangosteen Blossom
    Saffron
    Base
    MuskAmber
    AkigalawoodVetiver

    Notes both fragrances share

    Community taste

    The community verdict

    Community verdict: With Love vs. Magic Mango
    With LoveMagic Mango
    Score3.5/53.5/5
    Longevity6-10 hours6-10 hours
    Sillagemoderatemoderate

    No varnish

    Real talk

    With Love earned its reputation by doing something rare in celebrity fragrance territory, using real materials. Mangosteen blossom and cocobolo wood give it an unusual aromatic tension that rewards.With Love
    Magic Mango takes the throwaway mango fragrance, the kind that disappears quickly and leaves nothing behind, and gives it a spine. The drydown is where this earns its name.Magic Mango