Skip to main content
    Silloria
    BrandsNotesPerfumers
    Log inSign up

    Side by side

    Good Girl vs. Y

    Good Girl by Carolina Herrera bottle

    Good Girl

    Carolina Herrera
    Eau de Parfum2016
    Clearly related
    Y by Natura bottle

    Y

    Natura
    Eau de Parfum2008
    New comparison

    Is Good Girl better than Y?

    Good Girl rates higher with the community and wears longer on skin.

    Why this score
    Performance proximity
    Accord profile overlap
    Gender alignment
    VanillaBergamotSandalwoodMuskAmber
    SweetVanillaWoodyamberPowdery

    This match is a verified relationship from our fragrance graph. The score weighs each fragrance's notes, accords, mood, occasion, weather fit, gender, and performance — the same scale as the badges on every “reminds of” rail.

    The essentials

    What's different between Good Girl and Y?

    Key facts: Good Girl vs. Y
    Good GirlY
    ConcentrationEau de ParfumEau de Parfum
    Launched20162008
    GenderFemaleFemale
    PerfumerLouise TurnerVerônica Kato
    Best seasonFallFall

    Scent DNA

    How do Good Girl and Y smell?

    Good Girl

    Sweet
    White Floral
    Vanilla
    Warm Spicy
    Cacao
    Woody
    Tuberose
    Amber

    Y

    Floral
    Fruity
    Vanilla
    Woody
    Powdery
    Citrus
    Sweet
    Amber

    Shared between both fragrances

    The pyramid

    What notes do Good Girl and Y share?

    Top
    AlmondCoffeeBergamotLemon
    PeachPlumBergamotBlackcurrantMandarin Orange
    Heart
    TuberoseJasmine SambacOrange BlossomBulgarian RoseNeroliOrrisIris
    FrangipaniFreesiaNutmegChestnut
    Base
    Roasted Tonka BeanChocolateCacaoVanillaPralineSandalwoodMuskAmberCashmere WoodCashmeranPatchouliCedar
    AmberVanillaCoumarinSandalwoodMusk

    Notes both fragrances share

    Community taste

    Which performs better, Good Girl or Y?

    Community verdict: Good Girl vs. Y
    Good GirlY
    Score4/53.5/5
    Longevity6-10 hours4-6 hours
    Sillagestrongmoderate

    No varnish

    What do reviewers say about Good Girl and Y?

    Love it or find it too much, Good Girl refuses neutrality. The coffee-almond opening is its signature move, and the sweet drydown demands attention.Good Girl
    The powdery drydown is where it lives, that vanilla warmth following you around. The nutmeg and chestnut keep it interesting, adding warm spice that balances the sweetness.Y

    The hunt

    Where to buy Good Girl and Y

    Best price by size: Good Girl vs. Y
    Good GirlY
    1 oz$91.00ecosmetics—
    1.7 oz$130.00ecosmetics—
    2.7 oz$88.95fragranceshop—
    5.07 oz$124.95fragranceshop—

    Cheapest in-stock offer per size. Retailer links support Silloria at no extra cost to you.

    Good to know

    About Good Girl vs. Y.